Just buy another set of joycon controllers, put the scratched up ones in that box, then return them with the original receipt.
If you have your receipt, you can prove when you bought it.
Just insist that Walmart wouldn’t process an exchange.
Can you return controllers to Walmart?
Unopened video game software, Cricut™ cartridges, Music and Pre-recorded movies may be returned with a receipt. Controllers aren’t considered hardware are they? If it’s 90 days I can use the original receipt.
Can you return Joycons?
“Customers will no longer be requested to provide proof of purchase for Joy-Con repairs,” the internal customer service details say. “Additionally it is not necessary to confirm warranty status. If a customer requests a refund for a previously paid Joy-Con repair  confirm the prior repair and then issue a refund.”
How much are Joy cons at Walmart?
The versatile Joy-Con offers multiple surprising new ways for players to have fun. Two Joy-Con can be used independently in each hand, or together as one game controller when attached to the Joy-Con grip (sold seperately).
Can I return opened headphones to Walmart?
Generally, merchandise purchased in store or on http://Walmart.com can be returned or exchanged within ninety (90) days of purchase with or without a receipt.” If the headphones are sold as video game hardware they must be returned WITH a receipt within 15 days to get a refund.
What does Walmart do with returned items?
Well, Walmart in its own right stands as a certain quality guarantee. And some items basically are returned unopened and are still brand new. This merchandise is sold at a huge discount as the retailer looks to offload such merchandise and make as much profit from it as possible.
Does GameStop buy damaged controllers?
GameStop will usually take broken controllers. They would knock some money off via a refurb fee, but you could trade it in guilt free if it’s really bothering you.